Current:Home > BackHow to Sell Green Energy-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
How to Sell Green Energy
View Date:2024-12-25 01:54:27
By Sahil Kapur, Guardian
Fox News has revealingly declined to air an ad that emphasizes the national security perils of remaining dependent on oil in a call for clean energy reform. The decision by the network – primarily a communications arm for the Republican party’s right flank – underlies an important lesson for proponents of energy legislation as they unveil their legislation this Wednesday: it’s wiser to sell reform on the basis of national security and jobs, rather than the environment or climate change.
"Every day Congress doesn’t pass a clean energy climate plan our enemies get stronger," says the ad, which uses menacing imagery of Iran and urges lawmakers to enact legislation to "cut our dependence on foreign oil" and "cut oil profits for hostile nations." The spot, created by the veterans group VoteVets, is airing on CNN and MSNBC, but was deemed "too confusing" by America’s top-rated cable news network, reported Ben Smith of Politico. Fox didn’t elaborate.
The link between oil dependence and national security isn’t a new concept, but it’s one that makes Republicans – and by extension Fox News – uncomfortable. They delight in their image as safety hawks but hope to scuttle President Obama’s energy bill, so they don’t want this to become a battle over security. Thus Democrats would be wise to get behind this narrative if they want America to face up to the energy realities of the 21st century.
For the disastrous Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, far from invigorating the fight for energy and climate change reform, has weakened its prospects in Congress – a clear sign that environmental concerns alone, no matter how grave, won’t spur Washington into action. Times have really changed, because this wasn’t always the case.
The 1969 Santa Barbara oil spill brought us Earth Day and the National Environmental Policy Act. The 1989 Exxon Valdez tragedy paved the way for a stronger Clean Air Act. Today, the BP spill, shaping up to be the worst ecological disaster in US history, hasn’t induced opponents of stronger environmental regulations to concede an inch. President Obama remains committed to lifting a longstanding moratorium on offshore oil drilling in vast swaths of coastal areas. What gives?
For starters, the belief that humans are contributing to global warming has consistently been declining nationally. Chalk that up to a relentless and extravagant campaign by the fossil fuel industry and conservatives, whose agendas are threatened by the realities of the climate change, to manufacture doubts about universally accepted science. Second, the recession has dampened the appeal of environmental action, which most perceive as less immediate and a threat to their bank accounts.
The policy priorities of Americans shine a light on this. A Pew Research Centre survey in January found that the top three issues on voters’ minds are the "economy," "jobs," and "terrorism." "Energy" came in 11th, the "environment" 16th and "global warming" 21st. This is in spite of the fact that, as the Associated Press reported last November, "climate change has worsened and accelerated beyond some of the grimmest of warnings" in 1997, the year of the Kyoto Treaty.
Thus Republicans and right-wing Democrats aren’t fazed by the spill. In fact, House Republican leader John Boehner and Democratic senator Mary Landrieu said it emphasizes the need for more oil drilling. The clean energy industry can’t meaningfully compete with fossil fuels absent a price on carbon (something economists might call "internalising an externality"), which special interest-backed lawmakers won’t easily support.
The best chance, then, for progressives to break the gridlock and launch a serious debate in Washington about alternative energy – in which the rest of the Western world and even China is racing ahead – is to streamline their messaging and make sure Americans know it would produce enormous long-term benefits in the way of green jobs and domestic security – by ending reliance on hostile foreign regimes.
Democratic Senator John Kerry and independent Joe Lieberman will unveil a comprehensive energy bill on Wednesday, likely without the support of Republican Lindsey Graham, who backed out on Friday. As proponents of reform work to drive their message home, they would be smart to heed the political lesson of the Gulf spill, and focus on the energy-related concerns that capture the attention and support of Americans.
(Published with permission of the Guardian)
See also:
Eminent U.S. Climate Researchers Stand United on Science, Policy Action
Skeptics Exaggerating Science Scandal to Derail Copenhagen Climate Talks
Governors See Jobs on the Path to Clean Energ, Efficiency
(Oil tanker under military escort photo via U.S. Navy)
veryGood! (65)
Related
- This is Your Sign To Share this Luxury Gift Guide With Your Partner *Hint* *Hint
- Taylor Swift could win her fifth album of the year Grammy: All her 2025 nominations
- NFL Week 10 picks straight up and against spread: Steelers or Commanders in first-place battle?
- NY YouTuber 1Stockf30 dies in fatal car crash 'at a high rate of speed': Police
- Horoscopes Today, November 13, 2024
- How Harry Hamlin’s Pasta Sauce Transformed Real Housewives Drama into a Holiday Gift That Gives Back
- Did Ravens get away with penalties on Bengals' two-point conversion attempt?
- Los Angeles Lakers rookie Bronny James assigned to G League team
- 'Treacherous conditions' in NYC: Firefighters battling record number of brush fires
- Money in NCAA sports has changed life for a few. For many athletes, college degree remains the prize
Ranking
- Roy Haynes, Grammy-winning jazz drummer, dies at 99: Reports
- Partial list of nominees for the 2025 Grammy Awards
- Mariah Carey Shares Rare Photo of Her and Nick Cannon's 13-Year-Old Son
- Trump victory spurs worry among migrants abroad, but it’s not expected to halt migration
- Wendi McLendon-Covey talks NBC sitcom 'St. Denis Medical' and hospital humor
- The Colorado funeral home owners accused of letting 190 bodies decompose are set to plead guilty
- Brianna LaPaglia says ex-boyfriend Zach Bryan offered her a $12M NDA after breakup
- Winter storm smacks New Mexico, could dump several feet of snow
Recommendation
-
Amazon Black Friday 2024 sales event will start Nov. 21: See some of the deals
-
California air regulators to vote on contentious climate program to cut emissions
-
Nordstrom Rack Clear the Rack Sale Insane Deals: $18 Free People Jumpsuits, $7 Olaplex, $52 Uggs & More
-
Despite Climate Concerns, Young Voter Turnout Slumped and Its Support Split Between the Parties
-
Reese Witherspoon's Daughter Ava Phillippe Introduces Adorable New Family Member
-
Christina Hall Officially Replaces Ex Josh Hall With Ex-Husband Ant Anstead on The Flip Off
-
Powerball winning numbers for November 6 drawing: Jackpot rises to $75 million
-
Prince William reveals Kate's and King Charles' cancer battles were 'brutal' for family